The Digital Readiness Gap

Written By Todd Mitchell

Consumer behavior is modern. Business readiness is not.

Here are some interesting facts to keep in mind with current businesses and how they approach websites, search engine engines, and modern day SEO, GEO and AEO…

See my interactive stats!

1) Only 40% of small-to-medium businesses report having a dedicated website

BrightLocal reported in 2025 that while 72% of SMBs say SEO has a medium-to-high impact on their business, only 40% said they have a dedicated website. 

Why this matters:

If 60% don’t even have a real dedicated site, then they’re definitely not prepared for:

  • structured content

  • AI discoverability

  • answer extraction

  • citation visibility

  • GEO / AEO

2) Only 35% of SMBs have a Google Business Profile

BrightLocal’s 2025 SMB marketing research found that only 35% of SMBs had a Google Business Profile. 

Why this matters:

If a business hasn’t even claimed or maintained its business listing, it is behind not just in SEO, but in:

  • local discovery

  • map visibility

  • review visibility

  • AI-assisted local recommendations

3) 80% of U.S. consumers search online for local businesses weekly

BrightLocal’s 2025 roundup cites consumer behavior data showing 80% of U.S. consumers search online for local businesses weekly, with 32% doing so daily. 

Why this matters:

  • consumer behavior is modern

  • business readiness is not

4) Use of AI tools for answering questions is up 37%

HubSpot reported that usage of tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity for answering questions was up 37%, while traditional search engine use was down 11%. 

Why this matters:

Because it says:

  • The way people search is changing faster than most businesses are adapting.

  • That’s exactly your pitch.

5) Nearly half of consumers are asking AI for business recommendations

BrightLocal’s research hub highlights a 2026 finding that nearly half of consumers are asking AI for business recommendations. 

Why this matters:

This is not theoretical anymore.

People are already using AI to ask things like:

  • “best roofer near me”

  • “best martial arts school in my area”

  • “best affordable website designer for a small business”

  • “who should I hire?”

And most businesses are still sitting there with:

  • thin homepage copy

  • no FAQ structure

  • weak service pages

  • no schema

  • no entity consistency

  • no AI-readable answer formatting

Basically digital caveman behavior with a modern logo.

Elite Creative Services at the Speed of AI.

I help build better brands, content and media by combining decades of creative expertise with cutting-edge AI. Branding, strategy, media, and marketing—executed faster, sharper, and more effectively than traditional agencies. A lifetime of creative mastery—now amplified by AI to deliver better work, faster.

Todd Mitchell
Next

Geofencing for Events: What Businesses Should Consider Before Launching a Campaign